TTRPG Wiki

Compare tabletop RPG systems to find your next game

Daggerheart vs Shadowdark RPG

Compare Daggerheart and Shadowdark RPG side by side. See differences in complexity, dice, genre, and more.

DaggerheartShadowdark RPG
GenreFantasyFantasy
TagsNarrative, Collaborative, Fiction-First, Character Building, Character-Driven, Drama, Combat-Heavy, Resource Management, Fear & Stress Mechanics, Strong GM SupportDeadly, Dungeon Crawl, Rules-Light, Theater of the Mind, Roll to Cast, Random Tables, Resource Management, Inventory Management, Random Character Creation, Strong GM Support
Core MechanicPlayers roll two d12s, add a trait and modifiers, and meet or beat a Difficulty to succeed. The higher die grants the player Hope or gives the GM Fear, even when the action succeeds. Matching dice produce a critical success. Adversary attacks use d20 plus a modifier against Evasion.Roll a d20 plus the relevant stat modifier and meet or beat the difficulty class or Armor Class. Advantage and disadvantage use two rolls and keep the better or worse result.
Dice2d12, d20d20
ComplexityMediumLow
AvailabilityFree core rulesFree quickstart
Runnability5 of 5 book tools5 of 5 book tools
LicenseDarrington Press Community Gaming License (DPCGL 2.0)Shadowdark RPG Third-Party License Version 1.1
Third-Party PublishingCommercial publishing allowed — Community gaming licenseCommercial publishing allowed — Shadowdark RPG Third-Party License
Summary only, not legal advice. Check current terms before publishing.
PublisherDarrington PressThe Arcane Library
Year20252023
LanguagesEnglish, French, German, Italian, PortugueseEnglish, French, Italian, Portuguese
Best ForGroups who want fantasy campaigns built around character relationships and changing ability loadouts. Battles suit tables that share the spotlight without a fixed initiative order.Groups who want dangerous dungeon expeditions driven by resource choices and player ingenuity. Suits campaigns where recovering treasure matters more than defeating every monster.
Highlights
  • Hope can activate character abilities or add a backstory-based Experience to a roll.
  • Players share the spotlight freely until a failure, a Fear result, or GM intervention shifts it.
  • Each class combines two domains into a loadout of up to five active ability cards.
  • Torches burn for one hour of real time, putting a time limit on dungeon exploration.
  • Gear slots make carrying treasure compete with supplies needed to survive the return trip.
  • Procedural generators let the GM create dungeons and encounters during play.
Considerations
  • The spotlight has no fixed turns or action allotment, requiring the group to share opportunities to act.
  • Recalling inactive domain cards outside a rest can cost Stress.
  • Resting restores resources but also gives the GM Fear to spend on further threats.
  • Low starting hit points make a few successful attacks potentially fatal.
  • Class talents are rolled at odd-numbered levels, limiting control over advancement.
  • Social interaction relies mainly on spoken arguments and GM judgment rather than a dedicated conflict subsystem.