TTRPG Wiki

Compare tabletop RPG systems to find your next game

Dogs in the Vineyard vs Smallville Roleplaying Game

Compare Dogs in the Vineyard and Smallville Roleplaying Game side by side. See differences in complexity, dice, genre, and more.

Dogs in the VineyardSmallville Roleplaying Game
GenreHistorical, FantasySuperhero, Modern
TagsNarrative, Fiction-First, Character-Driven, Tag-Based, Drama, Collaborative, Improvisation, Roleplay-Heavy, Social Combat, Strong GM SupportLicensed IP, Superpowers, Character-Driven, Drama, Narrative, Collaborative, Worldbuilding, Roleplay-Heavy, Fear & Stress Mechanics, Strong GM Support
Core MechanicRoll a d4–d10 pool from relevant Stats and Relationships. Players Raise with two dice and See by spending dice that match or exceed the Raise. Traits, belongings, and escalation add dice as they enter the conflict. Seeing with three or more dice earns Fallout. Giving concedes the stakes.Roll a d4–d12 pool built from one Value and one Relationship, with an Asset die if applicable. Add the two highest dice. Dice showing 1 are Complications and never count. Plot Points can add dice to the pool before the roll or include more rolled dice in the total afterward. Tests normally pit your roll against the GM's Trouble pool. Ties go to the GM. Contests exchange action and reaction rolls until someone Gives In or fails to beat the previous total and takes Stress. Giving In concedes the opponent's demand but avoids Stress.
Diced4–d10 dice poold4–d12 dice pool
ComplexityMediumMedium
AvailabilityPaidOut of print
Runnability4 of 5 book tools4 of 5 book tools
LicenseProprietaryAll Rights Reserved
Third-Party PublishingNo verified route foundNo verified route found
Summary only, not legal advice. Check current terms before publishing.
Publisherlumpley gamesMargaret Weis Productions, Ltd.
Year20042010
LanguagesEnglish, Italian, German, Polish, SpanishEnglish
Best ForGroups who want episodic frontier drama built around difficult moral judgments and arguments that can escalate into violence.Groups who want superhero stories driven by relationship drama, where the player characters' convictions and loyalties clash with each other as often as they face villains.
Highlights
  • Escalation supplies fresh dice at the risk of harsher consequences, making continued opposition a choice about what the stakes are worth.
  • Fallout changes Traits and Relationships to carry conflict consequences into later play.
  • The town-creation ladder builds crises from interconnected grievances without prescribing how the Dogs should resolve them.
  • Challenging a Drive triples its die for one roll but steps it back for the episode, turning a crisis of conviction into Growth.
  • Group character creation builds a shared map of people and places that supplies material for later episodes.
  • When an opponent fails to beat your action result, they take Stress rather than concede your demand, making Giving In a separate choice.
Considerations
  • The Faith's patriarchal theology supplies concrete grievances in the town-creation rules and needs deliberate rewriting for another religious framework.
  • Conflicts abstract range and movement into narrated actions rather than measured positioning.
  • The GM must challenge the Dogs' judgments without preparing a preferred solution.
  • Creating an original cast through Pathways takes a few hours of group work before the first episode.
  • Episode preparation centers on conflicts between player characters rather than a unified party's shared objective.
  • Winning a Contest cannot kill a character by itself, because killing in a Contest requires that character's player to Give In and accept death.