TTRPG Wiki

Compare tabletop RPG systems to find your next game

Ashen Stars vs The Whispering Vault

Compare Ashen Stars and The Whispering Vault side by side. See differences in complexity, dice, genre, and more.

Ashen StarsThe Whispering Vault
GenreSci-FiHorror
TagsInvestigation, Mystery, Mission-Based, Ship-Based, Space Opera, Resource Management, Character-Driven, Strong GM Support, Skill-Based, CrunchyMission-Based, Mystery, Investigation, Superpowers, High-Power, Character-Driven, Atmospheric, Weird, One-Shot Friendly, Strong GM Support
Core MechanicOrdinary tests roll a d6 plus ability-pool points spent before rolling, succeeding by meeting or beating the difficulty. Investigative abilities work differently: a core clue is simply given when the right ability is used, no roll needed, with point spends buying extra benefits.Roll a number of d6s equal to the relevant Attribute. Take the highest single die or the largest sum of matching dice, then add the applicable Skill Bonus. Meet or exceed the GM's Difficulty to succeed. Spend one Karma to reroll any chosen dice while keeping the others.
Diced6d6 dice pool
ComplexityHighHigh
AvailabilityFree quickstartPaid
Runnability5 of 5 book tools3 of 5 book tools
LicenseAll Rights ReservedAll Rights Reserved
Third-Party PublishingCommercial publishing allowed — GUMSHOE Community on DriveThruRPGNo verified route found
Summary only, not legal advice. Check current terms before publishing.
PublisherPelgrane PressPhilip Reed Games
Year20112003
LanguagesEnglishEnglish
Best ForGroups who want episodic space mysteries with a shared ship and recurring personal subplots. Cases put the crew's pursuit of justice in tension with its need to earn a living.Groups who want supernatural horror investigations with powerful, inhuman protagonists. It suits episodic hunts across different eras or campaigns protecting one recurring location.
Highlights
  • Automatic core clues keep missed information rolls from blocking a case.
  • Reputation changes the wait between contracts, connecting ethical choices to the crew's upkeep bill.
  • Ship combat assigns different attack modes to crew stations, spreading decisive actions across specialists.
  • Each Hunt gives the group a concrete objective of investigating and repairing a breach in reality.
  • Mastered powers allow improvised effects paid for with Karma.
  • Consistent portrayal of the Keys that preserve a Stalker's human identity earns one part of the Experience award.
Considerations
  • Investigative pools normally refresh only when a case ends, making extra benefits a case-long budget.
  • The rules assume a working Laser crew; fugitive campaigns require changes to that framework.
  • Ship battles use abstract goal-point races rather than positional movement on a tactical map.
  • The Forbiddance punishes interference with unrelated mortals or major historical events.
  • Supernatural abilities can consume the same Vitality used to withstand injury.
  • Power interpretations and unusual combat situations depend on GM judgment rather than detailed rules for every case.