TTRPG Wiki

Compare tabletop RPG systems to find your next game

Against the Darkmaster vs The One Ring

Compare Against the Darkmaster and The One Ring side by side. See differences in complexity, dice, genre, and more.

Against the DarkmasterThe One Ring
GenreFantasyFantasy
TagsCrunchy, Combat-Heavy, Deadly, High-Fantasy, Journey, Character-Driven, Roll to CastJourney, Corruption, Character-Driven, Tactical, Resource Management, Inventory Management, Low-Fantasy, Exploration, Licensed IP, Strong GM Support
Core MechanicRoll d100 + skill bonus against a difficulty threshold for skill checks, or against an opponent's defensive bonus for attacks. Rolls of 01–05 are automatic failures (fumbles); rolls of 96–00 are open-ended, allowing a second d100 roll added to the first for explosive results. Attack rolls that exceed the target produce hits on weapon-specific attack tables, with high results triggering critical strikes that cause injuries, bleeding, and conditions beyond simple hit point loss.Roll a d12 Feat Die plus d6 Success Dice equal to the relevant skill rating, then total them against a target number. Gandalf’s rune succeeds automatically, while the Eye counts as zero and causes automatic failure for Miserable heroes. Sixes on successful rolls grant superior results.
Diced100d12 + d6 dice pool
ComplexityHighHigh
AvailabilityFree quickstartPaid
Runnability5 of 5 book tools5 of 5 book tools
LicenseProprietary (open00 SRD planned)Proprietary
Third-Party PublishingNot yet researchedNo verified route found
Summary only, not legal advice. Check current terms before publishing.
PublisherOpen Ended GamesFree League Publishing
Year20202021
LanguagesEnglish, ItalianEnglish, Czech, French, German, Italian, Japanese, Polish, Portuguese, Spanish
Best ForGroups who want an epic good-versus-evil campaign with deep character creation, detailed travel mechanics, and crunchy percentile combat with critical hit tables: especially fans of Rolemaster or MERP looking for a modernized take.Groups who want Middle-earth campaigns where dangerous journeys and the struggle against corruption shape their heroes.
Highlights
  • Character creation combines Kin, Culture, Vocation, and Background into highly differentiated characters with personal Passions that mechanically drive play.
  • Detailed overland travel system with terrain-specific hazard tables, foraging, camping, and safe haven mechanics.
  • Magic system with 30+ Spell Lores and over 300 spells, available to all Vocations at different costs.
  • The Darkmaster creation system lets the GM build a campaign-defining antagonist with servants, artifacts, and a dark stronghold.
  • Journey roles give each hero responsibility for the company’s travel.
  • Hope improves rolls while Shadow threatens heroes with lasting flaws.
  • Fellowship phases provide recovery and personal undertakings between adventures.
Considerations
  • 574-page core book requires significant reading investment before first play.
  • Open-ended d100 rolls and critical hit tables can produce extreme outcomes that swing encounters unpredictably.
  • No published setting: the GM must build or adapt one, though the included introductory campaign provides a starting framework.
  • Character creation involves multiple layered steps (Stats, Kin, Culture, Vocation, Skills, Backgrounds, Passions) that can take an entire session.
  • The core’s cultures and virtues tie character options closely to Middle-earth.
  • Carried equipment can make injured or fatigued heroes Weary.
  • Repeated corruption can force a hero to retire.