TTRPG Wiki

Compare tabletop RPG systems to find your next game

Carbon Grey RPG vs Deep Sky Ballad

Compare Carbon Grey RPG and Deep Sky Ballad side by side. See differences in complexity, dice, genre, and more.

Carbon Grey RPGDeep Sky Ballad
GenreHistorical, FantasySci-Fi, Post-Apocalyptic
TagsCrunchy, Tactical, Corruption, Roll to Cast, Licensed IP, Pulp ActionCrunchy, Ship-Based, Tactical, Character-Driven, Drama, Pulp Action, Diceless
Core MechanicRoll a pool of d6s equal to attribute + skill, sum the dice, and beat a Difficulty Number from 5 (Very Easy) to 30 (Extremely Difficult). One die in every pool is the Wild Die: a 6 grants an Advantage (Hero Point gain, success upgrade, or aid to an ally) and a 1 hands the GM a Complication that can deepen a failure. Margins above and below the DN scale results from Partial Success up to Exceptional Success and from Ordinary Failure down to Catastrophic Failure. Hero Points (start at 6) fuel doubled die codes, rerolls, and injury-level reductions.Blackjack System: each player and the GM draw from their own poker deck (cards 1–10 in each suit, no face cards). On a Challenge, draw two cards, then up to (Attribute) more, then remove up to (Skill) cards from the table. The remaining hand must reach the difficulty (Easy 16, Medium 18, Hard 19, Very Hard 20, Extreme 21) without exceeding 21. Hitting exactly 21 before the elimination phase is a Critical Success; busting over 21 is automatic failure regardless of the target. Aces count as 1 or 11. Emotional Bonds with crewmates can be spent during play to fuel near-superhuman cinematic abilities.
Diced6 dice poolDiceless
ComplexityMediumHigh
AvailabilityFree quickstartFree quickstart
Runnability3 of 5 book tools2 of 5 book tools
LicenseProprietaryProprietary
Third-Party PublishingNot yet researchedNot yet researched
PublisherMagnetic Press PlayWinged Lion Games
Year20222023
LanguagesEnglishEnglish, Italian
Best ForGroups who want dieselpunk WWI-flavored heroics (trench fighting, airship dogfights, espionage, and court intrigue) with an opt-in reality-warping subsystem that physically and mentally scars characters who lean on it.Groups who want a Space Western centered on cinematic crew drama and modular spaceship combat, with a card-based resolution that turns every challenge into a poker hand. Designed for a Posse of adventurers who share ownership of an interstellar ship and chase wealth across the wreckage of a fallen galaxy.
Highlights
  • Wild Die mechanic builds tier-based outcomes into every roll: a 6 grants an Advantage the player can spend on extra Hero Points, an upgraded success, or aid to an ally; a 1 hands the GM a Complication that can turn an ordinary failure into a Catastrophic one.
  • Continuity Flux skills (Manipulate, Divine, Transmogrify) let characters bend reality but each use raises a tracked Surge Count, and a roll-low check at session end against accumulated Corruption Points can permanently strip an attribute, transform the character into an enemy-controlled stone demon, or erase them from existence.
  • Character Persona stack (Quirks rolled on a d66 table, Obligations to factions or ideals, and Remarkable Abilities) pays out Skill Points at the end of any session the player honored their Obligation, and a session in which the character switches allegiance grants no Skill Points at all.
  • Card-based resolution gives players visible information about their hand before committing to a Challenge, turning each roll into a press-your-luck decision.
  • Six-axis Hardboiled System tracks Loyalty/Rivalry, Affection/Hatred, and Trust/Grudge between Posse members at multiple stages, granting bond-fueled cinematic abilities tied to those relationships.
  • Spaceship combat uses a hex-grid module map with simultaneous six-phase turns (Maneuvers, Movement, Shield, Mine Release, Fire, Resolution), requiring each crewmember to act from their assigned station.
  • Modular ship construction lets the Posse design custom hulls under Energy and Charge limits and upgrade modules over the campaign.
Considerations
  • Combat layers multi-action penalties, scale rules between personal, vehicle, and grand-scale targets, weapon properties like Bypass ARM and Continuous, and dedicated subsystems for grenades, artillery bombardment, flak, hail of bullets, and minefields: each with its own DN, reaction options, and damage table.
  • Continuity Flux powers are gated behind the Latent Flux Talent ability or GM-granted shard exposure, so a party without one is shut out of the reality-bending side of the setting unless the GM hands out access.
  • Setting is tightly tied to the Carbon Grey graphic novel (eight named nations with specific factions, mythologies, and political alignments), so adapting the system to a homebrew dieselpunk world means cutting the lore that anchors most published episodes.
  • Heavy mechanical load: separate subsystems track Vigor, Resources, Fatigue, Mental Fatigue, Emotional Bond stages and tokens, Wear, and Spaceship Conflict each with their own rules.
  • Card-based resolution requires a full poker deck per player plus a separate GM deck (an official Discord bot exists as a substitute).
  • Spaceship combat's simultaneous-phase structure expects every player to participate from a different ship module and slows considerably with larger crews.
  • Designed specifically for Space Western themes within the New Frontier setting: not a generic engine for other genres.