TTRPG Wiki

Compare tabletop RPG systems to find your next game

Band of Blades vs Belly of the Beast

Compare Band of Blades and Belly of the Beast side by side. See differences in complexity, dice, genre, and more.

Band of BladesBelly of the Beast
GenreFantasy, HorrorPost-Apocalyptic, Horror
TagsFiction-First, Playbook-Driven, Grimdark, Mission-Based, Faction Play, Deadly, SurvivalSurvival, Weird, Player-Only Rolls, Grimdark, Resource Management, Faction Play
Core MechanicForged in the Dark: roll a d6 dice pool equal to your action rating and read the highest die: 6 is a full success, 4–5 is a partial success with consequences, 1–3 is a bad outcome. Position (controlled, risky, desperate) sets the stakes, and players spend stress to resist consequences. Play alternates between a mission phase (specialists and rank-and-file Legionnaires execute one primary and one secondary mission) and a campaign phase, where each player runs a permanent Legion Role (Commander, Marshal, Quartermaster, Spymaster, or Lorekeeper) making strategic decisions about routes, supply, intel, and personnel as the army retreats toward Skydagger Keep.Roll 1 base d6 plus up to 5 Instinct Dice spent from a refillable pool plus any Advantage Dice, capped at 10 total. Each die is a success on a face value set by your relevant Skill Rank: Rotten (6), Acceptable (5+), Capable (4+), Brilliant (3+). Tasks have a Difficulty (successes needed), Severity (how much failure hurts), and optional Threshold (successes removed before counting). Players roll for everything; the GM never rolls. Spent Instinct Dice are gone until earned back by acting in line with your two Instincts.
Diced6 dice poold6 dice pool
ComplexityHighMedium
AvailabilityPaidFree quickstart
Runnability5 of 5 book tools3 of 5 book tools
LicenseForged in the DarkProprietary
Third-Party PublishingNot yet researchedNot yet researched
PublisherEvil Hat Productions / Off Guard GamesSigil Stone Publishing
Year20192016
LanguagesEnglish, French, Spanish, ItalianEnglish
Best ForGroups who want a campaign-length military fantasy where the Legion as a whole is the protagonist: character death is expected, players cycle through different soldiers each mission, and strategic decisions about routes, supply, and intel are split across the table rather than held by the GM.Groups who want grim survival horror in a confined weird-fiction setting where character Instincts and a scavenging mission cycle (not heroic combat) drive every session, and who are comfortable with a GM who never rolls and tunes threats by feel.
Highlights
  • Players rotate through Specialist, Soldier, and Rookie playbooks across missions rather than playing fixed characters, so attrition lands without ending personal arcs: the Legion endures even when individual soldiers fall.
  • Each player also holds a permanent Legion Role that drives the campaign phase, splitting army-management decisions across the table instead of leaving them with the GM.
  • Time and Pressure clocks turn the campaign into a race against the Cinder King: advancing toward Skydagger Keep burns time, but lingering builds undead pressure that escalates the difficulty and lethality of future missions.
  • Instinct Dice tie character drives directly to dice pool depth: acting on your two Instincts earns dice you spend to survive future rolls, so leaning into your character's flaws is how you stay mechanically competent.
  • Tasks have three independent dials (Difficulty, Severity, and Threshold), letting the GM build a D1/S4/T0 assassin or a D5/S1/T2 vault door that feel mechanically distinct without an enemy stat block.
  • Succumb and Transcend let any player auto-resolve a Task or Scene by embracing or permanently renouncing an Instinct: Succumb leaves the character Ashamed and unable to Advance until they atone, while Transcend removes that Instinct and its dice income from the sheet forever.
Considerations
  • The campaign phase (mission generation, spy deployments, supply, advance roll, Lorekeeper annals) takes substantial time between missions and only works if every player engages with their Role.
  • Building a deep personal arc for a single Legionnaire is structurally difficult because characters rotate between missions: emotional investment lives with the Legion rather than any one soldier.
  • The campaign is built around a single fixed arc ending at Skydagger Keep, with a defined map, locations, and Chosen/Broken roster.
  • There is no open-ended sandbox mode, and a full campaign runs 12–20 sessions.
  • Players roll for everything and the GM never rolls, so every Enemy, Hazard, and Sickness is a Difficulty, Severity, and Threshold the GM sets by feel during play rather than reading from a stat block.
  • Combat uses abstract Hand/Arm/Reach/Near/Far ranges with no grid, no movement tracking, and no initiative: the GM calls turn order from the fiction.
  • Setting material includes normalized slavery, frenzy-mad cannibals, and an in-fiction gender framing where women are treated as more 'precious' than men due to reproduction: the book flags the last point in a sidebar and suggests GMs skip it if uncomfortable.